My Way -Private Waterfront Estate with Breathtaking Views and Pristine Shoreline

"My Way" has been cherished by the same family for over 40 years! Spend your days boating across the interconnected lakes, hiking nearby trails, or exploring local lore. In every season, this exceptional waterfront property delivers the perfect blend of relaxation, privacy, and outdoor adventure for an unforgettable escape.
This stunning 8-bedroom retreat offers over 300 ft of pristine, sandy shoreline on First Lake and comfortably sleeps up to 18 adults. Thoughtfully designed for multi-family vacations, retreats, or special occasions, this gracious home offers unparalleled views and privacy.
Inside, you’ll find expansive living areas with vaulted ceilings, abundant natural lighting and panoramic views of the lake and McCauley Mountain. The fully equipped kitchen features a large refrigerator and two dishwashers. The generous dining space makes it easy to host family meals or celebratory dinners, while multiple lounging areas provide plenty of room to spread out. A wraparound deck off the living area features plenty of seating and a grill.
The master bedroom is directly off the living area and has amazing lake views. This unique master also features an ensuite with a walk-in shower, a Jacuzzi tub, plus separate vanity. Four bedrooms have ensuite bathrooms all with stand-up showers. The other 4 bedrooms share 3 separate full bathrooms.
The lower level features a spacious game room complete with a pool table and foosball for hours of entertainment. A walkout basement leads directly to the level grassy lawn, making it easy to transition from indoor games to lakeside activities. This level also includes a convenient kitchenette and bar area—perfect for entertaining without heading upstairs.
Set in a tranquil cove and bordering a scenic peninsula, the property’s waterfront offers a rare sense of seclusion with minimal boat traffic—perfect for peaceful swims and relaxed days by the water. The sandy lake bottom provides easy, comfortable access for all ages, making it ideal for wading, swimming, and launching kayaks or paddleboards right from your private shoreline. For added peace of mind, the home has a backup generator, ensuring uninterrupted comfort throughout your stay.
Step outside to enjoy your private waterfront—whether you’re soaking in the serene views from the deck, gathering around the firepit, or just chilling. A large private dock provides ample space for boating, lounging, and taking in the surrounding beauty. Evenings are perfect for watching the sunset reflect off the calm waters and unwind under a sky full of stars. Welcome to My Way!

Rates & Availability

Cancellation Policy: One hundred percent (100.00%) of the total booking charges will be refunded if the cancellation is made more than 30 days prior to the arrival date of the reservation. For cancellations made within 30 days prior to the arrival date, no refund will be issued.

Location

Old Forge, New York

Amenities

Guest Reviews